AI will replace dumb jobs, at first...
The first jobs to go are always the dumb ones. At first...
The ones that repeat, that follow scripts, that require obedience over insight. And when technology learns how to do those jobs better than we can — faster, cheaper, without lunch breaks — society doesn’t thank the machines. It panics.
Blake Montgomery’s recent article in The Guardian lays it out plainly: AI is breaking the first rung of the career ladder (Montgomery, 2025). Entry-level roles — the proving grounds for generations of workers — are vanishing. Programmers, journalists, customer service reps, even paralegals are being automated before they’ve had time to laminate their new ID badges. Executives in tech are predicting that half of all entry-level white-collar jobs could disappear in five years. The Federal Reserve already reports a spike in underemployment among recent grads. The market isn’t waiting for AI to take over. It’s hiring like AI already has.
Historically, this isn’t new. Labor-saving devices have always started by eliminating the lowest, most repetitive tasks. The washing machine, vacuum cleaner, dishwasher, and electric iron didn’t liberate people — they liberated housework. The jobs disappeared, but the people didn’t. They reorganized their lives. Society built new expectations, invented new jobs, redirected people toward different forms of contribution.
But what’s different now is speed.
In the past, these transitions took decades. The farmhand became a factory worker. The typesetter became a technician. Even when jobs disappeared, the process gave people time — time to adjust, retool, retrain. Today’s shift is happening in a matter of quarters, not generations. You graduate in May and by July, the job you trained for is gone — not because it was bad, but because a model trained on the open internet learned to do it first.
This kind of change is dangerous, not because of AI itself, but because entry-level jobs are more than jobs. They’re social infrastructure. They teach young people how to work, how to collaborate, how to fail and recover, how to navigate power and responsibility. They’re the onboarding mechanism for adulthood. If we remove that rung, we don't just strand workers — we unmoor the next generation from the systems we assume they’ll someday lead.
Societies that survive disruption do one thing well: they intervene. They don’t wait for the market to fix itself. They build training programs, offer transitional support, redefine roles. When automation came for the factory, we built public schools. When it came for the office, we built universities. Now it’s coming for the internship — and we need to ask: what do we build this time?
Because when labor-saving devices change the world slowly, culture adapts. But when they move fast — when the first rung is gone before anyone sees it breaking — we owe it to the young and vulnerable to build another way up.
Reference
Montgomery, B. (2025, June 3). Will AI wipe out the first rung of the career ladder? The Guardian. https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2025/jun/03/ai-entry-level-jobs
The first jobs to go are always the dumb ones — and this time, it’s entry-level workers.
ReplyDeleteAI isn’t coming. It’s already here. And it’s coming for the job you were supposed to get after graduation.
Generative AI is cutting out internships, assistant roles, junior positions — all the places people start. According to top execs, half of all entry-level white-collar jobs could vanish in five years (Montgomery, 2025). Companies aren’t even replacing people. They’re just waiting for the bots to catch up.
Historically, labor-saving tech like the washing machine, vacuum, dishwasher, and electric iron liberated housework, not people. But it took decades. Time to adapt. Today? This AI wave is hitting faster than we’ve ever seen.
And here’s the real danger: entry-level jobs aren’t just jobs — they’re where you learn how to work. Take those away, and we don’t just lose paychecks — we lose the first step into adult society.
When change happens this fast, we can’t wait for the market to adjust. We have to build something new. Or risk leaving an entire generation with nowhere to start.