We Are the Machines Now: AI, Anarchism, and the Ghosts of the Megamachine: How old anarchist theories and post-structuralist philosophy might explain why ChatGPT creeps you out.

The Concept of the Machine: From Mumford to Deleuze and Beyond

Blog Edition: AI, Ethics, and the Machine Metaphor


For most of human history, machines were something we built. Tools to grind grain, engines to move goods, or, if you're Lewis Mumford, ominous forces that could shape our very souls. Today, machines aren't just tools; they think, recommend, even talk back. With AI growing faster than our laws or ethics can catch up, it might be time to dust off some of the deepest, weirdest, and most radical critiques of machines ever penned.

So let me take you on a journey from the 19th-century anarchists to the post-structuralist philosophers of the late 20th century, and finally into the age of AI. We'll explore how figures like Lewis Mumford and Gilles Deleuze thought about machines—not as hardware, but as social, psychological, and moral metaphors. And we’ll ask: what happens when machines start thinking back?


Machines as Metaphors: From Anarchism to Technocracy

Anarchists like Peter Kropotkin imagined decentralized, non-hierarchical cooperation among individuals. To them, "the machine" wasn't just a physical tool—it was a potential threat to human autonomy when embedded in systems of state control or capitalism. Kropotkin believed humans could organize themselves without coercion, but warned that industrial systems tended to do the organizing for us.

Enter Patrick Geddes and Lewis Mumford. Geddes, a biologist turned city planner, believed that the rise of machines corresponded with different historical "ages." The latest, the "neotechnic" era, was dominated by totalitarian order and the regimentation of everyday life. Mumford, building on Geddes, sharpened the idea: machines could extend human potential, but also restrict and define it. When used without ethical restraint, they formed a "megamachine" — a society-wide system in which humans became interchangeable parts.

Sound familiar, AI folks?


Post-Structuralist Spin: Deleuze, May, and the Identity Problem

Flash forward to the 1990s. Philosopher Gilles Deleuze, along with Felix Guattari, exploded traditional ideas of identity and structure. In Anti-Oedipus and A Thousand Plateaus, they redefined the machine. For them, a machine wasn't something built but something connected. A machine is a node in a network: your body, your job, your Spotify playlist. Everything connects to something else.

This vision overlaps with Mumford in some surprising ways—but there's a key difference. Deleuze's machines have no essence. They are pure potential, pure motion. Mumford, by contrast, sees organic life as free because it has no fixed function—but he still believes in certain values, like autonomy and ethical regulation. Deleuze is more radical: he wants to abandon any fixed moral center entirely.

Todd May, a philosopher of post-structuralist anarchism, tries to square this circle. He wants the freedom and decentralization of anarchism, but the philosophical subtlety of Deleuze. Yet May struggles to ground his ideas in political practice. Where Mumford talks about city planning, land use, and social policy, May stays in the realm of theory.


Why This Matters in the Age of AI

If you've read this far, you may be asking: what does any of this have to do with ChatGPT, algorithmic bias, or that weird feeling your phone is watching you?

Here's the link: All these thinkers grapple with a basic question—what makes us human in a world of machines? For Mumford, machines threaten to override our moral agency. For Deleuze, they threaten to dissolve our very selves. Today, AI systems are poised to do both.

Take algorithms that decide who gets a loan, a job interview, or parole. They might appear neutral, but they're part of a megamachine: a system whose logic can perpetuate injustice without any single person intending it. Or think about social media algorithms that shape our beliefs, desires, and identities. If you agree with Deleuze, you're already a machine among machines.

But here's the kicker: we're no longer just watching the machine work. We're interfacing with it. We're feeding it data, and it's feeding us ideas. That’s new.


Where Do We Go From Here?

So what do we take from all this?

  1. Decentralization isn’t enough. Kropotkin was right that networks can liberate, but they can also oppress. Decentralized doesn’t mean neutral.

  2. We must question the ends. Mumford believed the machine should serve human flourishing, not efficiency alone. As we build AI systems, we need to define what flourishing means.

  3. Don’t forget the body. Deleuze was obsessed with embodiment and affect. Tech discourse often forgets we’re not just minds uploading data—we’re still squishy, vulnerable creatures.

  4. Theory must meet practice. This is where May gets stuck. Philosophy is vital, but without action, it becomes a machine of its own.


Final Thought: Machines Don’t Sleep, But We Do

In the end, the real danger isn't that machines will rise up, Terminator-style. It's that we'll become too much like them—efficient, obedient, optimized. The thinkers I’ve discussed today remind us that resistance isn’t just about politics or protest. It's about remembering that we are not machines. Not yet.

And maybe, if we listen to these old ghosts, we won’t become them.


References

  • Deleuze, Gilles, and Guattari, Felix. Anti-Oedipus: Capitalism and Schizophrenia. University of Minnesota Press, 1983.

  • Deleuze, Gilles, and Guattari, Felix. A Thousand Plateaus: Capitalism and Schizophrenia. University of Minnesota Press, 1987.

  • Fishman, Robert. The American Planning Tradition. Johns Hopkins University Press, 2000.

  • Hall, Peter. Cities of Tomorrow. Blackwell Publishers, 1996.

  • Kropotkin, Peter. Fields, Factories and Workshops. G.P. Putnam’s Sons, 1913.

  • May, Todd. The Political Philosophy of Poststructuralist Anarchism. Penn State University Press, 1994.

  • Mumford, Lewis. Technics and Civilization. Harcourt Brace, 1934.

  • Mumford, Lewis. The Myth of the Machine: The Pentagon of Power. Harcourt Brace, 1970.

  • Weir, David. Anarchy and Culture: The Aesthetic Politics of Modernism. University of Massachusetts Press, 1997.


Comments

  1. TLDR We built machines to serve us—then forgot to ask what we were serving.

    From Mumford’s megamachine to Deleuze’s desiring-machines, the warnings are clear: when tools become systems and systems become culture, we stop noticing what they’ve taken from us. AI is not just a mirror of human thought—it’s the newest gear in a centuries-old engine.
    If we don't choose the direction, the machine will.

    Now’s the time to ask—what kind of future do we want these systems to make?

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Trump as the Generational Destroyer (but not the Final Word)

Influence of African English Varieties on LLM Language a Deep Research Report